I can't make decisions!

I've been working on a new website for the past couple of days and I could really use some advice! Although I liked my old site, I wanted something a little more professional looking. More pizzazz! More fun!

Fortunately, Wix.com has some really awesome (and free!) templates and I've been playing with a few of them. Now I'm wondering...which layout is better? 

Version #1

Version #2

I like the whimsy of Version #1, but I also like the bold background of Version #2. Yeargh! I'm so indecisive. Which one do you guys like more?

Help!

(By the way, I had a ton of fun making these sites! I'd highly, highly recommend Wix.com if you're thinking about making your own website.)